Interviewed January 21, 2025.
Carol J. Adams is an activist of more than 50 years and author of numerous books. She is one of the world’s leading theorists in the area of vegan feminism and served on the board of Feminists for Animal Rights (FAR). Aside from preliminary work on what would become The Sexual Politics of Meat (1990) in the 1970s, some of Adams first work around intersections of gender and species was spurred by her subscription to The Beast, a British radical animal rights journal of the early 80s. This was where Adams first came across the now infamous and highly inspirational “Ursula Hamdress,” a pornified image of a pig displayed at an Iowa farm fair, covered by her colleague Jim Mason in an issue of The Beast.
At that time, Adams also came into correspondence with a British feminist working on intersections of vegetarianism, lesbianism, and feminism who was discouraged by failed attempts to gain support from a feminist conference in their campaign against vivisection.
Encouraged by these encounters, Adams began to reach out to and expand her dialogue with other feminists and posted an advert in the “Chicken Lady” section of Off Our Backs and other feminist publications. She met Josephine Donovan (who would go on to coauthor several important books with Adams) as a result. Donovan responded to one of her posts around 1980, but Adams failed to respond for many years, so overwhelmed was she with anti-racism, migrant justice, and housing activism in her local community as well as a hotline for battered women that was headquartered, at first, at her house. That said, her engagement with these various human rights campaigns deeply informed her own learning and theory, what would become a lifelong commitment to immersing herself in the work of non-white theorists: “That injustice [racism], that and abortion rights, are two injustices that just, you know, are deep within me, that I will always feel impassioned about.”
After moving to Texas with her partner who had taken a ministry position there, Adams was able to finish The Sexual Politics of Meat while raising her young son. Back in 1976, in the research for the first version of the book, she interviewed 40-50 women in Boston where she was studying at the time. That 1976 book was originally intended to include a chapter on recipes, and, she intentionally collected recipes that were vegan, or “complete vegetarian.” Veganism, she explains, is vegetarianism unmodified (in line with MacKinnon’s theory and lexicon of “feminism unmodified”), but she continued to use vegetarian in the original–vegan–sense of the word. This linguistic choice, she would later decide, did need reworking to maintain its original meaning. In preparation for the 35th anniversary of The Sexual Politics of Meat, she decided it was time to make clear her vegan politics:
Times have changed. “Vegetarian” carries a conservative meaning now. It didn’t carry that meaning in 1990. You know, I tried to do a book with “vegan” in its title in the year 2000, and the publisher was a vegan, and he said people don’t know that word enough.
Across her career, she has witnessed a number of shifts in the animal rights movement. The disappearance of grassroots activism from the 1980s and 1990s, for one, she identifies as a serious loss. The entrenchment of the large organizations frequently disrupted whatever local efforts persisted.
PETA would come into a community and maybe do a naked campaign, and then when the local grassroots group wanted to do something and then they contacted the media, the media would say, ‘Well, is anybody gonna be naked? We’ll come out if someone’ s naked’.” So, there was this ripple effect on suppressing grassroots viability.
Adams also notes the sexist gender politics that proliferated in grassroots groups as well. These collectives, for instance, were often headed by women, but media would reach out to men for comments. “This happened over and over again.” Meanwhile, FAR may have valued women’s contributions and prioritized women’s leadership, but it, too, ran into difficulties in a professionalizing movement space. As the organization grew, Adams reflects, the tension between national and local chapters with regard to autonomy became difficult to manage. She was not involved in these organizational or structural decisions, but she recalls the strain FAR experienced in its transition.
FAR, of course, was also contending with a movement largely unfavorable to feminist organizing:
I think the whole question of what is successful in a movement, we have to first phrase, ‘Well, what’s the movement?’ I mean, the animal rights movement was so patriarchal right from the beginning.
Today, she continues to take particular issue with the male encroachment over that social justice work, particularly in the animal rights movement. “There was a deliberate effort in the early 70s to masculinize the movement,” Adams suggests. She points to Singer’s publication of Animal Liberation and the active campaign to establish it as the inspiration of the women-led modern animal rights movement as a case in point. The proliferation of Singer’s utilitarianism and its current rendition in the form of “effective altruism” has shown to be, she adds, “very out of touch with social change movements.”
This set the movement back, she explains, by championing a teleological approach that framed animal rights as the “next” campaign after racism and sexism, rather than placing animal rights within these still ongoing battles. A variety of intersectional conversations with anti-speciesism and veganism that had been taking place across social justice spaces, she fears, has been subsequently supplanted by Singer’s linear approach: “I think that hurt us. […] I sort of mourn what got lost because Animal Liberation took over the conversation.” It sidelined a rich discourse of vegan feminism, she clarifies: “I’m sort of sad about that.” “I think rewriting the 70s is very important.” Martin Rowe (co-founder of Lantern Books) had jokingly considered publishing a book on the history of the animal rights movement (Is a Woman the “Father” of Animal Liberation?) with no mention of men at all in an effort to balance the historical record.
Aggravating this theoretical sexism, she adds, is persistent gender inequality in activist spaces: “You’ve got vegan men very anxious not to be seen as vegan like women.” The creation of new terminology, she suggests, such as “hegan,” “plant-based,” and “plant-powered,” are misogynistic attempts to differentiate men’s veganism from that of women’s: “Vegan carried gendered associations.” Indeed, Adams charges that the biggest barrier to animal liberation is misogyny. “The animal rights movement has always struck me as problematic,” she adds, consequently unsure if she even called herself an “animal rights activist” in the 1980s. Within days of publishing The Sexual Politics of Meat, she began hearing from women who had been sexually harassed, or worse, in the movement. So many women were not only harmed by this systemic abuse but also left the movement (or were forced out) as a result.
Here, Adams draws on correspondence with the late radical feminist Andrea Dworkin for insight. Dworkin, who composed one of the first blurbs for The Sexual Politics of Meat, shared with Adams her concern for women who join the animal rights movement but not the feminist. “Being involved in a movement on behalf of yourself can be threatening,” she suggests, invoking an insight of Catherine MacKinnon. Given the greater numbers of women in the movement surviving these toxic conditions, Adams and Dworkin focus not so much on the many accomplishments of these women predominating in animal rights but rather what they are likely not addressing or accomplishing due to gender inequality, harassment, fear, and internalized sexism. Adams questions how the success of the animal rights movement can truly be measured as a result, “because all I see are the costs and consequences for women.” Theory, for this reason, she sees as absolutely necessary for guiding a sustainable, equitable activism. It should be honored in the movement repertoire.
Today, Adams understands vegan feminism as “hands off the bodies of others”:
You know, hands off […] making animals pregnant, forcing women to be pregnant, compulsory pregnancy… eliminate compulsory pregnancy, then we’d have no animal agriculture because there’s no pregnant animals producing the victims of nonvegans. […] If we really had a policy of hands off pregnant women, we would have to have achieved equality and misogyny would, you know, be something that people were afraid to articulate rather than something that is part of a presidential campaign.
Vegan feminism, for Adams, is also positive and constructive: “it’s beautiful; it’s delicious.” And, though it is respectful, she clarifies, it is neither quiescent nor silent.
Learn more about Carol J. Adams and their writing on their website.